Our organization is currently plagued by all the things referenced in this article. It has been “overmanaged and underled” for quite some time now. Part of it is due to the industry (energy) we are in. Energy industries typically tend to be late adopters and highly monolithic in their approaches. As a technology professional I struggle every day due to two compelling reasons – there is no governance (even if it exists, it has insignificant) and momentum of change. I feel that our entire department is treated like internal consultants whose opinions are solicited but not exactly followed. Driving change almost always has come from external sources (consultants, industry experts, etc.) There was one particular incident where our department’s recommendation EXACTLY matched what the industry experts said but when it came to giving credit where it was due, no points for guessing who eventually received it!
I believe the concept of transition versus change cannot be over emphasized. Employee engagement affects the organization tremendously. Effective leadership should heighten the emotional attachment an employee feels for his/her organization and thereby increase the discretionary effort exerted. The other concept described in the article that caught my attention was the one on “operator error”. Right now, our organization is driving change (on a sequential basis) through external consultants and internal staff groups. None of us are aware of how the change impacts us since it is all being done behind closed doors. This has created an environment of massive speculation, fear and insecurity. Lack of alignment or in certain cases misalignment has resulted in inflexibility with our systems and incoherent collaboration between business areas. Redundancy of processes, systems and information is wide spread and the weird thing is that some of our “leaders” know about it and yet, do nothing about it.
I often hear the rumblings of goals and objectives that our company needs to achieve. But in my opinion they are often too amorphous or just a BHAG. Our department goals are clear and compelling but we live in a perennial fear of them not aligning with the organization’s goals.
I get a good share of criticism for some of the changes that I personally implemented in the organization and sometimes wonder “Is it worth it?”.